For authors

Bring the paper
you already wrote.

Use your current manuscript. At least ten peers rank its summary. The top 30% by expected impact advance to full review.

A shallow drawer folded from printed ivory manuscript pages stands halfway open on clay. Six manuscripts sit inside. A seventh projects over the lip, with a pencilled correction changing "mean" to "median."
What's still in your drawer? Send the manuscript you already have. Your peers give it a fresh read.

One manuscript, intake to decision

What happens after you send it?

Four stages. Intake is open.

  1. Give the first readers a fair summary.

    Bring your PDF or a preprint link, with coauthor approval. AI drafts a short account of the claim, evidence and limitations. You correct it, and the version you approve is the one peers compare.

  2. Take your turn on the ballot.

    Your team orders ten other summaries by expected impact, then orders the same ten by the talks you would go to in person. You owe one double ballot for each paper you submit.

  3. If you advance, read the finalists.

    About the top 30% become finalists. Technical flags come back to you for correction. One peer from your team then writes 3–5 full reviews of other finalists.

  4. Read the decision and its reasons.

    Impact placements and full-review evidence are combined under a rule announced before intake. There is no chair vote. The target is a decision within 30 calendar days of complete, eligible intake.

How submission works

How submission will work

Four steps, each with its own color and label. The form opens when you choose Submit a paper. The ribbon below shows the third step as an example.

  1. 01Manuscript
  2. 02Summary
  3. 03TermsStep 3 of 4
  4. 04Receipt

Manuscript. Your PDF or preprint link. Summary. You correct and approve the draft. Terms. You see your fee status and the peer work involved, then confirm. Receipt. You get a record of what you submitted and the cohort date.

Cost and review workload

What would one paper cost? What would two?

All fees are proposed launch terms. The first 1,000 submissions each calendar month enter free.

Proposed fees and peer work, in US dollars
Your submissionsWithin the first 1,000 that monthAfter the monthly waiverPeer work you owe
One paper, not accepted$0$50One double ballot (rank ten summaries twice)
One paper, accepted$500$550One double ballot, plus 3–5 full reviews if it reached the finalists
Two papers, neither accepted$0$100Two double ballots
Two papers, one accepted$500$600Two double ballots. Each finalist paper adds its own 3–5 reviews

Each paper has its own waiver status, and you see yours before confirming. $500 is due only on acceptance. See the full proposed terms.

Illustrative

What a decision letter will say

A short excerpt from an invented letter about the sample paper. No cohort has run.

Through to full review. This manuscript advanced on the expected-impact ranking. At least ten different peers placed the summary in both rankings. The next stage is a full read of the evidence and claims.

Illustrative excerpt for "When should a small model ask for help?" Expected impact band 6–10%, talk-interest band 1–5%.

Every team gets a record like this, whatever the outcome. The talk-interest band is kept apart from the publication decision.

After a conference decision

Still believe in that paper?

Send the manuscript you have. You'll see the date of the next decision and the peer work involved before you submit.

A prior rejection or withdrawal is not a barrier. The founding research group had seven papers in one conference cycle and seven more from earlier rounds still in a drawer. That is why this journal exists.