For journals, societies and conference tracks

Bring peer ranking to one track.

Run one comparative pilot cycle on manuscripts you already receive, under your own rules, and compare the result with your current process.

Two ways to run the cycle

One cycle, one track or one intake cohort. You choose how much of your decision the pilot carries.

Shadow trial and live trial compared
QuestionShadow trialLive trial
Who decides?Your incumbent process makes the actual decisionsThe contracted rule decides
What the pilot doesRuns alongside and records what it would have decidedProduces the decisions you publish
What you learnWhere the two processes agree and where they splitWhether the rule holds up in your real cycle
Risk to your authorsMinimal. Your process still decides, and authors see no change unless you choose to tell them.Set by the contract and announced to authors

What you sign for

The budget holder agrees these terms before intake opens.

Volume and timing

A submission cap and a delivery date.

Who is eligible

Eligibility and a conflicts policy, and how authors are told.

Data and handoff

Data permissions and the format of what is handed back.

Method and fee

The comparison method, and a fee priced per cycle.

What you get back

Ranked shortlist

The papers that move forward, in order.

Coverage report

How many distinct peers ranked each paper.

Decision audit

How each decision was reached, so it can be checked.

Exports

Files in the handoff format you chose.

After delivery we sit down with you and reconcile expert hours, organizer interventions and where the selection disagreed with yours. Pilots are priced per cycle, and the price depends on volume. Ask for a quote.

Other routes exist and suit other venues: rolling journals such as TMLR, special tracks such as DMLR, OpenReview-based systems and local meetups. A pilot adds one more comparison point. It does not replace them.

Ask about a pilot

Tell us about the track. We reply with questions and a quote.